I've been pondering some thoughts my friend Sean posted over on
his blog about worship (i.e., music) styles at various churches he's attended recently.
Here's a snip:
I'm not a fan of the music at my church (no, you read that right; I'm in a full disclosure mood). The band is very, very good -- it isn’t quality that I'm not a fan of, but rather performance style.
You see, they "lead" worship in what I call "concert style." The emphasis here is on serving G-d through quality -- so the band works to sound the best it can. Decisions are based primarily on what sounds good on the stage. And the audience is invited to sing along if they so wish.
Now, the reason I was thinking about this is because Sean and I go to the same church. So I walked in to worship this Sunday with Sean's words in mind.
And I have to say, I almost completely disagree.
Yes, our church band is very, very good. (I took a non-believing friend to a service last December -- she turned to me with a gasp after the first number and said, "They sound like U2!" I would take that as an unbiased thumbs up for the quality of the band.)
But I don't think that's a bad thing. And I don't think it detracts from worship.
Here's what detracts from worship for me (assuming a similar style, etc.): A band that draws attention to itself. A band whose leader feels the need to preach between songs (thus usually drawing attention to himself). A band whose singers "show off" with all sorts of riffs or variations on the melody on a regular basis. Our band does none of those things. They just stand up there and play really, really well.
Here's something else that detracts from worship for me: A band (or worship leader) who just isn't very good. I cringe when someone hits the wrong chord. Or when a singer hits the wrong note. Or when the drummer (or the organist, for that matter) loses the rhythm, slows down, speeds up inappropriately.
Sometimes I visit churches that aren't musically sophisticated. I listen to the mediocre guitar player (probably about as good as I used to be), and I try to use the moment to be grateful for how fabulous our music us at Bel Air. But after a while (especially if that mediocre worship leader is using worship time to tell a story about him/herself, or to preach in an otherwise trite manner, as so often happens), I start looking around the congregation. And I find myself wondering... Out
all these people, this is their only choice for worship leader? No one else here has any musical gifts whatsoever?
I stand with C.S. Lewis on this issue:
A choir should sing in tune, or it should not sing at all.
Now, to be fair, Sean isn't objecting to how good our band is. He's objecting, as I understand it, to the "performance" orientation he senses, and also to the congregation's responding to the band with applause.
Two separate issues, I think.
First, the "performance" issue. You know, I've been at our church for a very long time. I was here before we
had a "contemporary" service, when all we had was a traditional choir. A choir that, if you were watching them, you would never have accused of having a "performance" orientation.
But I was also on the task force that first studied the idea of a "contemporary" service. And I saw how nastily, how untruthfully, and how selfishly that pristine-looking choir
fought the idea of a contemporary service. They really didn't give a rip whether there were potential worshippers who might be better served by a different kind of music. The mere thought that they could be asked to give up "their" time up front was a horror to them. And they lied, slandered, schemed to try to keep that from happening. Take it from me, I was the road kill in their way -- they were devastating, they were ungodly.
Their entire attitude was one of "performance." You never would have known it, though, from watching them on Sunday mornings. (Most of the individuals from that era, only 7 or 8 years ago, have left the church -- things didn't go "their" way eventually, so they tucked up their robes and walked.)
Just because someone is technically proficient, even truly excellent, doesn't say a thing about whether it's a "performance" or "worship."
As to the issue of applause... well, I'm a little closer to Sean on this issue. I don't clap in church as a matter of course. Sure, I'll applaud for the second-graders being presented their Bibles, because I want them to understand that we as a church support them, that we, well, applaud them on their accomplishments. And let's face it, here in L.A. at least, applause is a pretty universally acknowledged sign of approbation.
But I rarely applaud the band. Sometimes when they are so astonishing, when they have truly moved me, yes, I do applaud -- though to be honest, I feel I'm applauding God as much as or more than the band in those special moments. And I do understand why the pastor sometimes ends the service by applauding the band -- I know how much time the band must spend, individually and collectively, to
be that good, and I also can guarantee, based on my own years and years of Christian service, that virtually no one bothers to express appreciation for all that work.
I think what it boils down to is that we have one mode of communication (applause) that can communicate many things, and most often communicates appreciation for a performance. So when that mode of communication shows up in church, it can be misleading.
I love our worship. I love our band. I love how truly excellent they are. I love it that my guests are blown away by their excellence (which helps shatter the image they are likely to have of Christians as shoddy creators). I love it when the drummer does something unexpected, when the lead guitarist blows me away with an astonishing riff, when an unexpected chord changes the mood of a song.
Is there anything that bugs me about our worship, you ask. Oh you bet there is -- Would someone
please proofread the lyrics projected onto the screen?! It's vs. its. You're vs. your. "Crucifiction" -- I'm not kidding (I did call and raise a tad bit of hell on that one). Now
there's something that can pull me out of worship much faster than a band that can actually play!
But other than that, I'm proud to have been the road kill on the path to a service that ended up being what ours is today.